Buttondown Farm

Recent Home Sales $655,000 – $1,030,000 15 home sales in the last 5 years · excludes vacant lots

About the neighborhood

Buttondown Farm is a small single-family neighborhood in Zionsville made up of 48 homes on lots averaging about 0.44 acres. The zoning is R-SF-2, in keeping with the detached-house character of the community. Across 15 recent sales, homes have sold for an average of around $842,899, with the top of the range reaching $1,030,000, placing it among the higher-priced enclaves in the area.

The neighborhood has a homeowners association, managed by Traci Cawi, with dues of $50 per month. Shared amenities include a playground, giving families a common space within the community. Homes here feed into Zionsville Community Schools, with students attending Pleasant View Elementary School, Zionsville Middle School, and Zionsville Community High School.

With its modest collection of single-family homes, an active HOA at a low monthly cost, and a playground on site, Buttondown Farm is best suited to buyers seeking an established, family-oriented setting in the upper price tier of the Zionsville market.

Location and boundaries

Amenities and features

Nature & Recreation
Playground
Utilities & Infrastructure
Utilities
Water: Well • Sewer: Septic

Housing overview

Home Types
Single Family

Common questions

Recent home sales in Buttondown Farm have averaged $843,000. That figure is based on 15 finished-home sales recorded in the last five years, and excludes vacant-lot sales.

Yes, Buttondown Farm has a homeowners association with dues of about $50 per month, managed by Traci Cawi.

Buttondown Farm is served by Pleasant View Elementary School, Zionsville Middle School, Zionsville Community High School, part of Zionsville Community Schools.

Buttondown Farm amenities include a playground.

Homes in Buttondown Farm

52 Total

4611 St Johns Cir

Zionsville, IN 46077
5 bd 5 ba 3,264 sq ft 2003 1 ac
Last Sold Mar 2022 $821,500

4616 St Johns Cir

Zionsville, IN 46077
5 bd 5 ba 6,445 sq ft 2000 1 ac
Last Sold Jan 2019 $759,000

4621 St Johns Cir

Zionsville, IN 46077
6 bd 4.5 ba 3,590 sq ft 2002 1 ac
Last Sold Apr 2022 $1,010,000

4626 St Johns Cir

Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 3.5 ba 3,619 sq ft 2000 1 ac
Assessed Value $992,500

4631 St Johns Cir

Zionsville, IN 46077
4 bd 4.5 ba 4,387 sq ft 2003
Last Sold Jun 2024 $1,030,000

4636 St Johns Cir

Zionsville, IN 46077
4 bd 3.5 ba 4,591 sq ft 1969 1 ac
Assessed Value $737,500

4651 St Johns Cir

Zionsville, IN 46077
5 bd 4.5 ba 3,950 sq ft 2002 1 ac
Assessed Value $859,800

4656 St Johns Cir

Zionsville, IN 46077
4 bd 4 ba 2,617 sq ft 2000 1 ac
Assessed Value $783,900

4668 St Johns Cir

Zionsville, IN 46077
4 bd 4 ba 2,504 sq ft 1999 1 ac
Last Sold Apr 2011 $560,000

4671 St Johns Cir

Zionsville, IN 46077
5 bd 3.5 ba 4,026 sq ft 2003
Last Sold Jul 2021 $922,500

4676 St Johns Cir

Zionsville , IN 46077
5 bd 5.5 ba 4,930 sq ft 2002 1 ac
Assessed Value $995,500

4681 St Johns Cir

Zionsville, IN 46077
5 bd 4.5 ba 3,695 sq ft 2004
Assessed Value $1,259,300

4752 Madras Ct

Zionsville, IN 46077
4 bd 4.5 ba 3,664 sq ft 2002
Assessed Value $806,500

4757 Madras Ct

Zionsville, IN 46077
4 bd 4 ba 4,681 sq ft 1999
Assessed Value $1,001,800

4760 Khaki Ct

Zionsville, IN 46077
4 bd 3.5 ba 3,624 sq ft 2002 1 ac
Assessed Value $793,100

4762 Madras Ct

Zionsville, IN 46077
4 bd 4.5 ba 3,352 sq ft 2000
Last Sold Aug 2023 $655,000

4765 Khaki Ct

Zionsville, IN 46077
5 bd 5 ba 3,729 sq ft 2000
Assessed Value $813,400

4767 Madras Ct

Zionsville, IN 46077
5 bd 5.5 ba 3,490 sq ft 2002
Last Sold Sep 2020 $620,000

4770 Khaki Ct

Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 3 ba 3,461 sq ft 2002
Last Sold Nov 2019 $430,000

4772 Madras Ct

Zionsville, IN 46077
5 bd 4.5 ba 4,354 sq ft 2005
Last Sold Jul 2020 $675,000

4775 Khaki Ct

Zionsville, IN 46077
5 bd 4.5 ba 3,254 sq ft 2003
Last Sold Jun 2023 $751,000

4777 Madras Ct

Zionsivlle, IN 46077
Parcel record
Last Sold Jun 2025 $981,500

4780 Khaki Ct

Zionsville, IN 46077
5 bd 5.5 ba 3,248 sq ft 2002
Last Sold Jan 2014 $542,000

4782 Madras Ct

Zionsville, IN 46077
4 bd 3.5 ba 2,850 sq ft 2003
Last Sold Mar 2022 $745,000
Key facts
  • Total Homes 48
  • Total Acres 23 ac
  • Avg. Lot Size 0.44 ac
  • Avg. Sold Value $843,000
Schools
Elementary
Pleasant View Elementary School
ZCS
Middle
Zionsville Middle School
ZCS
High
Zionsville Community High School
ZCS
HOA details

$50

Per Month

Management: Traci Cawi

[email protected]

Jurisdiction
  • Zoning R-SF-2
  • Tax Dist. 06006