538 Nuthatch Dr

Zionsville, IN 46077

Town of Zionsville Zionsville Community Schools

Neighborhood: Sycamore Bend

Estimated value today

$458,000

Likely range $421,000 – $495,000

Last Sold May 2018: $264,000

How estimates work

Property Features

3
Bedrooms
1.5
Bathrooms
3,592
Sq Ft Total
1970
Year Built
  • Lot Size 0.461 acres
  • Above Grade 1,796 sq ft
  • Basement 1,796 sq ft, unfinished
  • Finished Area 1,796 sq ft
  • Garage 2-car attached, 560 sq ft
  • Heating Central warm-air heat
  • Cooling Central air
  • Fireplaces 1
  • Assessor Grade C+1
  • Condition Average

Improvements on record

Improvement Built Size
Utility shed 1993 104 sq ft
Structures and site improvements on the county assessor's 2026 record.

Sales History

Date Event Price
May 10, 2018 Sale $264,000
Sep 29, 2014 Sale $212,000
Recorded sale prices from public records. Not every transfer is captured. Every recorded sale on Nuthatch Dr →

Tax & Assessment

  • Parcel ID 060834000071000005
  • Assessed Land Value $19,900
  • Assessed Improvements $360,400
  • Total Assessed Value $380,300
Estimate your bill if you bought this home → How this assessment changed from last year →

Tax bills on record

Year Bill Rate
2025 · paid 2026 $2,981 0.88%
2024 · paid 2025 $2,949 0.95%
2023 · paid 2024 $2,801 0.92%
2022 · paid 2023 $2,558 0.91%
2021 · paid 2022 $2,421 0.98%
2020 · paid 2021 $2,477 0.97%
County tax records by assessment year; the rate is the bill as a share of that year’s assessed value.

Parcel Details

  • Deeded Acreage 0.461 acres
  • Property Class 510
  • Council District 4 (Sarah Esterline Sampson)

Utilities

  • Water Well
  • Sewer Septic
  • Electric Boone County REMC
Based on Town of Zionsville service-area maps and development filings.
Legal Description:
SYCAMORE BEND SEC 2 LOT 34

Location

Zoned schools

Elementary school
Pleasant View Elementary School
(317) 873-2376
Middle school
Zionsville Middle School
(317) 873-2426
High school
Zionsville Community High School
(317) 873-3355

Based on the 2026-27 list. Assignments group by neighborhood per the ZCS list and boundary map; confirm with ZCS.

See the full attendance map →

Follow this home

One email when something changes: the estimate, a sale here or nearby, or the assessment. Most weeks send nothing. No account needed.

Double opt-in; one-click unsubscribe in every email. We never share the list.

Internet providers

  • Fiber TDS Telecom to 1 Gbps
  • Cable Spectrum to 1 Gbps
  • DSL TDS Telecom
  • Fixed wireless Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile
Reported to the FCC for this home's census block (Dec 2025 data). Advertised top speeds, not guarantees. All Zionsville providers →

Flood zone

Zone X: minimal flood hazard
Outside the 1%- and 0.2%-annual-chance floodplains.
FEMA flood layer for Boone County (18011C), retrieved Jul 2, 2026. Reflects the parcel point, not the whole lot; informational, not a flood determination. Verify at msc.fema.gov.

Nearby homes

Sycamore Bend

536 Nuthatch Dr

Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 2 ba 1,524 sq ft 1974 0.52 ac
Est. today $365,000
Assessed Value: $307,200
Sycamore Bend

540 Nuthatch Dr

Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 2 ba 1,636 sq ft 1974 0.6 ac
Est. today $445,000
Assessed Value: $374,000
Sycamore Bend

534 Nuthatch Dr

Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 2 ba 2,976 sq ft 1974 0.77 ac
Est. today $554,000
Last Sold Jan 2024: $360,000
Sycamore Bend

542 Nuthatch Dr

Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 3 ba 2,275 sq ft 2003 0.76 ac
Est. today $1,013,000
Last Sold Jan 2016: $424,900
Sycamore Bend

537 Quail Valley Dr

Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 2 ba 1,796 sq ft 1974 0.69 ac
Est. today $482,000
Last Sold Apr 2023: $380,000
Sycamore Bend

535 Nuthatch Dr

Zionsville, IN 46077
4 bd 2.5 ba 2,214 sq ft 1974 0.58 ac
Est. today $506,000
Last Sold Nov 2025: $441,500