Location and boundaries
Amenities and features
Nature & Recreation
Utilities & Infrastructure
About the neighborhood
Carters Addition is a subdivision of 47 single-family homes in Eagle Township, Zionsville, Indiana. Most of the homes date from 1951 to 1970, and lots average 0.22 acres. The neighborhood is zoned R-V.
Recorded sales are the best guide to prices here. Across 16 recent recorded sales, prices have averaged $353,625, with the highest at $550,000. The neighborhood falls within Zionsville Community Schools; the assigned high school is Zionsville Community High School.
With mid-century homes on smaller lots and recent sale prices averaging in the mid-$300,000s, Carters Addition suits buyers looking for an established Zionsville neighborhood at a price below what much of the town's newer construction commands.
Recorded sales are the best guide to prices here. Across 16 recent recorded sales, prices have averaged $353,625, with the highest at $550,000. The neighborhood falls within Zionsville Community Schools; the assigned high school is Zionsville Community High School.
With mid-century homes on smaller lots and recent sale prices averaging in the mid-$300,000s, Carters Addition suits buyers looking for an established Zionsville neighborhood at a price below what much of the town's newer construction commands.
Housing overview
Home Types
Single FamilyWhat’s changing nearby
Nothing is on file with the town for this part of Zionsville right now.
Hear when something is filed near Carters Addition
One email a week at most, only when a Plan Commission or BZA filing touches this neighborhood. Quiet weeks send nothing.
Unsubscribe in one click. We never share the list. How the alerts work →
Homes in Carters Addition
47 Total190 N 9th St
Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 2 ba 1,490 sq ft 1958
Est. today
$419,000
Assessed Value: $302,500
195 N 9th St
Zionsville, IN 46077
2 bd 1 ba 1,282 sq ft 1958
Est. today
$391,000
Last Sold Nov 2022: $260,000
200 N 8th St
Zionsville, IN 46077
2 bd 1 ba 936 sq ft 1953
Est. today
$294,000
Assessed Value: $212,000
630 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
2 bd 1 ba 689 sq ft 1951
Est. today
$365,000
Last Sold Dec 2019: $215,000
635 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
2 bd 1.5 ba 1,208 sq ft 1961
Est. today
$461,000
Last Sold Sep 2020: $200,000
645 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
4 bd 2.5 ba 1,073 sq ft 1948
Est. today
$445,000
Assessed Value: $321,100
650 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 2.5 ba 1,671 sq ft 1957
Est. today
$666,000
Last Sold Sep 2020: $375,000
655 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 1.5 ba 1,145 sq ft 1958
Est. today
$330,000
Assessed Value: $237,800
660 W Poplar St
Zionsville , IN 46077
2 bd 1.5 ba 1,189 sq ft 1958
Est. today
$440,000
Assessed Value: $317,000
665 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 1.5 ba 1,364 sq ft 1957
Est. today
$349,000
Assessed Value: $251,700
670 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
4 bd 2 ba 1,750 sq ft 1957
Est. today
$554,000
Last Sold May 2026: $550,000
680 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 2.5 ba 1,484 sq ft 1958
Est. today
$446,000
Last Sold May 2018: $256,900
800 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
2 bd 1 ba 1,040 sq ft 1955
Est. today
$344,000
Last Sold Nov 2016: $130,000
810 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
4 bd 2 ba 1,800 sq ft 1955
Est. today
$456,000
Assessed Value: $328,600
820 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 1 ba 1,478 sq ft 1956
Est. today
$398,000
Last Sold Nov 2025: $375,000
830 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 1 ba 1,040 sq ft 1956
Est. today
$298,000
Assessed Value: $215,000
840 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 2 ba 1,618 sq ft 1957
Est. today
$431,000
Assessed Value: $310,700
855 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 2 ba 975 sq ft 1996
Est. today
$587,000
Assessed Value: $423,500
890 W Oak St
Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 1 ba 1,040 sq ft 1950
Est. today
$414,000
Assessed Value: $298,300
895 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 1 ba 1,107 sq ft 1956
Est. today
$538,000
Last Sold Jul 2025: $510,000
900 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 1 ba 912 sq ft 1955
Est. today
$370,000
Assessed Value: $266,600
905 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
1 bd 1.5 ba 912 sq ft 1958
Est. today
$267,000
Last Sold May 2023: $200,000
910 W Poplar St
Zionsville, IN 46077
3 bd 1 ba 960 sq ft 1956
Est. today
$283,000
Last Sold Jul 2020: $120,000
Common questions
The median recorded sale price in Carters Addition is $460,000, from 9 finished-home sales in the last three years. Vacant-lot sales are excluded. Records-based estimates put the typical home value today near $398,000.
No homeowners association is on record for Carters Addition.
66% (31 of 47 homes) were billed at Indiana's homestead rate on 2025 property-tax bills, which marks a home as its owner's primary residence. The rest are rentals, second homes, or recent purchases where the homestead filing hasn't caught up.
Carters Addition is served by Eagle Elementary School, Zionsville Middle School, Zionsville Community High School, part of Zionsville Community Schools. This is based on the district's housing-additions list for 2026-27. Approximate, because the district list does not name this neighborhood: matched by name, read from the district boundary map, or taken from the neighborhoods around it. Double-check the exact assignment. Assignments group by neighborhood per the ZCS list and boundary map; confirm with ZCS.
FCC filings as of Dec 31, 2025 report fiber from Metronet and AT&T, cable from Spectrum and Xfinity, and DSL from AT&T in Carters Addition. Satellite (Starlink, Viasat, HughesNet) also covers the area. Availability is tracked by census block, so confirm your exact address on the FCC National Broadband Map.